Politics

/

ArcaMax

Commentary: What power do ordinary citizens have to keep federal agents accountable?

Brian Kolp, Chicago Tribune on

Published in Op Eds

When I first sat down to write this piece last month, this was the opening paragraph:

Renee Good was not the first person to be shot and killed by a federal immigration agent, and she likely will not be the last. My quiet block in the Old Irving Park neighborhood in Chicago was not the first to be tear-gassed, and it will not be the last. As abhorrent as these events were, what makes the situation worse — and what people are only now starting to talk about — is that Immigration and Customs Enforcement and Customs and Border Protection agents are almost entirely immune from criminal and civil accountability.

Now, in the wake of the death of Alex Pretti, it’s more important than ever to raise the level of public awareness and discourse about the significant barriers that exist to holding ICE and CBP accountable for their actions.

To be sure, there is no reason to believe any federal prosecutor under the administration of President Donald Trump will ever bring criminal charges against an ICE or CBP/Border Patrol agent, and, so far, no state or local prosecutor has dared. One reason is the Supremacy Clause of the United States Constitution, which provides a strong legal defense to federal agents in state-based prosecutions. Another is the probability that an agent so charged would be successful in arguing to a judge they acted reasonably under the circumstances, particularly in cases involving the use of deadly force. But perhaps the most significant barrier to a state-based criminal prosecution of an ICE or CBP agent is the fact that the Trump administration can use the FBI to take over the investigation and prevent state and local authorities from accessing critical evidence, as they did following Good’s killing and are doing with the investigation into Pretti’s.

Worse still, unlike the way someone whose rights were violated by a state or local police officer can sue for money damages in federal court, federal law does not provide the same relief to victims of ICE and CBP’s brutality. This is because the Constitution does not provide a civil remedy for the violation of the Bill of Rights. Instead, Congress had to pass a law to allow for state and local government officials, such as police officers, to be sued in federal court for money damages. Congress passed this law — Section 1983 — six years after the end of the Civil War as part of the Civil Rights Act of 1871, also known as the Ku Klux Klan Act.

But Congress has never passed a Section 1983 equivalent for federal officials. In other words, there is no federal law that allows you to sue a federal officer for the violation of your federal civil rights. The only way to sue a federal agent for the violation of your constitutional rights is via a judicially created cause of action commonly referred to as a Bivens action. In short, the Supreme Court allowed Webster Bivens to sue six unknown agents of the Federal Bureau of Narcotics in 1971 for the violation of his rights under the Fourth Amendment. Since then, however, the Supreme Court has significantly limited its decision that relates to Bivens, so much so that unless your name is Webster Bivens and you’re suing six unknown agents, your odds of prevailing are incredibly low.

While most Americans will be surprised to learn this, the people calling the shots in the Trump administration and at the Departments of Homeland Security and Justice — Stephen Miller, Pam Bondi, Kristi Noem, Tom Homan — are well aware of these barriers to accountability for ICE and the CBP and are intentionally exploiting them. Miller has suggested on more than one occasion that ICE and CBP agents are “absolutely immune” from prosecution. While that’s not legally correct, he’s not far off in practical terms. The result is a federal immigration force that believes it can behave however it wants without fear of facing any real consequence for agents’ actions.

 

So where do we go from here? How do we change the landscape of the hellish dystopian nightmare we’re currently living in? The answer is simple: ICE and CBP agents should face the same criminal and civil liability under state and federal law as would a Chicago police officer. But that accountability will never come unless Congress and state and local leaders act, which is not as simple. Congress is as feckless and fractured as ever, and any state or local prosecutor who has the temerity to bring a criminal case against an ICE or Border Patrol agent for their lawless behavior will no doubt be on the receiving end of Trump’s weaponized Department of Justice.

Bleak as this reality may be, we as American citizens have an obligation to do all that we can to challenge the Trump administration’s lawlessness. We cannot be cowed into quiescence. We must loudly and publicly protest its abuses at every opportunity. We have to put maximal pressure on our elected leaders at the federal, state and local level to do everything in their power to bring accountability to the Trump administration. Imagine what could happen if every person reading this called their member of Congress and demanded the lawmaker refuse to fund DHS any further unless and until Congress passes a Section 1983 equivalent for federal officials.

Don’t wait until another American citizen is killed by their own government. Act now.

____

Brian Kolp is a former attorney for the city of Chicago’s Law Department and the Illinois attorney general’s office and a former prosecutor with the Cook County state’s attorney’s office.

___


©2026 Chicago Tribune. Visit at chicagotribune.com. Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.

 

Comments

blog comments powered by Disqus

 

Related Channels

The ACLU

ACLU

By The ACLU
Amy Goodman

Amy Goodman

By Amy Goodman
Armstrong Williams

Armstrong Williams

By Armstrong Williams
Austin Bay

Austin Bay

By Austin Bay
Ben Shapiro

Ben Shapiro

By Ben Shapiro
Betsy McCaughey

Betsy McCaughey

By Betsy McCaughey
Bill Press

Bill Press

By Bill Press
Bonnie Jean Feldkamp

Bonnie Jean Feldkamp

By Bonnie Jean Feldkamp
Cal Thomas

Cal Thomas

By Cal Thomas
Clarence Page

Clarence Page

By Clarence Page
Danny Tyree

Danny Tyree

By Danny Tyree
David Harsanyi

David Harsanyi

By David Harsanyi
Debra Saunders

Debra Saunders

By Debra Saunders
Dennis Prager

Dennis Prager

By Dennis Prager
Dick Polman

Dick Polman

By Dick Polman
Erick Erickson

Erick Erickson

By Erick Erickson
Froma Harrop

Froma Harrop

By Froma Harrop
Jacob Sullum

Jacob Sullum

By Jacob Sullum
Jamie Stiehm

Jamie Stiehm

By Jamie Stiehm
Jeff Robbins

Jeff Robbins

By Jeff Robbins
Jessica Johnson

Jessica Johnson

By Jessica Johnson
Jim Hightower

Jim Hightower

By Jim Hightower
Joe Conason

Joe Conason

By Joe Conason
John Stossel

John Stossel

By John Stossel
Josh Hammer

Josh Hammer

By Josh Hammer
Judge Andrew P. Napolitano

Judge Andrew Napolitano

By Judge Andrew P. Napolitano
Laura Hollis

Laura Hollis

By Laura Hollis
Marc Munroe Dion

Marc Munroe Dion

By Marc Munroe Dion
Michael Barone

Michael Barone

By Michael Barone
Mona Charen

Mona Charen

By Mona Charen
Rachel Marsden

Rachel Marsden

By Rachel Marsden
Rich Lowry

Rich Lowry

By Rich Lowry
Robert B. Reich

Robert B. Reich

By Robert B. Reich
Ruben Navarrett Jr.

Ruben Navarrett Jr

By Ruben Navarrett Jr.
Ruth Marcus

Ruth Marcus

By Ruth Marcus
S.E. Cupp

S.E. Cupp

By S.E. Cupp
Salena Zito

Salena Zito

By Salena Zito
Star Parker

Star Parker

By Star Parker
Stephen Moore

Stephen Moore

By Stephen Moore
Susan Estrich

Susan Estrich

By Susan Estrich
Ted Rall

Ted Rall

By Ted Rall
Terence P. Jeffrey

Terence P. Jeffrey

By Terence P. Jeffrey
Tim Graham

Tim Graham

By Tim Graham
Tom Purcell

Tom Purcell

By Tom Purcell
Veronique de Rugy

Veronique de Rugy

By Veronique de Rugy
Victor Joecks

Victor Joecks

By Victor Joecks
Wayne Allyn Root

Wayne Allyn Root

By Wayne Allyn Root

Comics

Christopher Weyant John Branch Al Goodwyn Eric Allie Daryl Cagle Ratt