CHARLOTTE, N.C. — Of all the questions moviegoers can come up with regarding the authenticity of the new “Roofman” movie, this one might stand as the biggest: At the time of his crimes, was Jeffrey Manchester even remotely close to as good-looking as Channing Tatum?

That, of course, is subjective. Meanwhile, many of the other “what’s true and what’s not” questions we expect to be raised by the film — based on Manchester’s brazen McDonald’s robberies, his bold escape from a North Carolina prison, and the bonkers series of adventures that saw him living in (and next to) a Charlotte Toys R Us while wooing a churchgoing single mom under false pretenses — can be answered much more objectively.

“Roofman” opened in theaters nationwide on Friday; so if you haven’t yet seen it but plan to, you may want to bookmark this page and come back to it after.

Because, obviously, spoilers abound.

If you have seen it, then let’s dive right in to our great, big fact check, which outlines numerous examples of the creative license the filmmakers took on their way to adapting Manchester’s life and crimes for the big screen.

In the movie: As the story begins, Jeffrey (played by Tatum) is in a tenuous off-again-on-again relationship with the mother of his three children, including very young twins and a daughter who turns 6 and then 7 in the first 15 minutes of running time. It’s implied that they reside in North Carolina (and, though it’s never made explicit, it’s suggested they’re in the Fayetteville area).

In real life: Somewhat true, somewhat false. Manchester was never a permanent North Carolina resident. He had lived near California’s Bay area for years. He was divorced in 1999, and during that period became estranged from his three children. In May 2000, he arrived in the Tar Heel state on an assignment as an Army Reserve sergeant; shortly thereafter, he wound up in the Charlotte area — where he would rob two McDonald’s over the course of just a few hours. At the time, his daughter was about 7, but his twin sons were actually a year older than her.

In the movie: Having broken into a Fayetteville McDonald’s through its roof, Jeffrey genially forces employees into the restaurant’s freezer — and in doing so, he makes sure they put on the coats they had worn to work (implying that it was wintertime).

In real life: More true than not, though there’s no record of him ever committing a robbery anywhere near Fayetteville. Also, this is somewhat nitpicky, but ... he actually was known for putting employees into the restaurant’s walk-in refrigerator. And FWIW, Mirvat Fayad says that when he robbed the McDonald’s she worked at in Belmont on the morning of May 20, 2000 — when the temp was about 65 degrees — he put them in the fridge after having the manager fetch for each of them a McDonald’s-uniform jacket (intended to be worn by employees who need to do work inside the refrigerators or freezers).

In the movie: As Jeffrey presents a new bike to his daughter at her seventh birthday party, police arrive to arrest him for his “Roofman” crimes.

In real life: False. He was arrested as he fled with cash he’d taken from the Belmont McDonald’s, after Fayad and her co-workers were able to break open the refrigerator’s door and call police.

In the movie: Jeffrey — who claims that he robbed 45 McDonald’s restaurants before being caught — is convicted of three counts of felony kidnapping. At a hearing on Feb. 4, 2004, a judge tells him, “Although you’re only being tried for one robbery, we know you’ve done many more,” then sentences him to 45 years in prison. (Jumping ahead a little here, but the movie suggests the whole Manchester saga played out over the course of two years. It actually spanned more than twice as long as that.)

In real life: True-ish, and false-ish. A jury convicted him of seven counts of kidnapping and one weapons offense, all related to the two N.C. robberies. He was sentenced to 32 to 45 years by a Gaston County judge — on Nov. 2, 2000. Authorities had been investigating him for at least 42 armed robberies in other states, but eventually retired those efforts.

In the movie: Jeffrey escapes from a Polkton prison by wedging a piece of plywood into the undercarriage of a large box truck, and then climbing up onto the plywood, where he could avoid being spotted by guards using under-vehicle search mirrors.

In real life: True. The film’s and history’s timelines realign here, too, with the escape taking place in June 2004. (What’s false about how that scene plays out, however, is that it has Manchester managing to get a fair distance away from the prison while riding under the truck; in actuality, he only got as far as an outbuilding, then had to slip away from there.)

In the movie: Jeffrey winds up in the Charlotte area and randomly decides that a Toys R Us store (shown late in the movie as being located in Pineville) would be a good place to hide out. He finds a difficult-to-access, walled-off area of the store — behind a display of kids’ bikes — where he creates a lair that includes a children’s mattress fitted with Spider-Man bedsheets and comforters. He manages to take control of the security cameras, sets up stolen baby monitors to spy on employees, uses the store as a playground at night, and eats stolen candy and baby food. The lair goes undetected for six months.

In real life: More true than not. The false parts include the fact that the store was actually on Independence Boulevard in Charlotte; as well as the fact that while he did live behind a wall in the Toys R Us for multiple months, that hideout was discovered by employees (when he happened to not be there). Around that time, he bored a hole through a wall on the opposite side of Toys R Us, into a closed-down Circuit City electronics store, where he created another lair behind a wall underneath a staircase.

In the movie: Leigh Wainscott (played by Kirsten Dunst) is introduced as an employee at Toys R Us and a recently divorced single mom of two girls — Dee, 11, and Lindsay, 16.

In real life: Vaguely true, but largely false. Wainscott (now Leigh Moore) worked in the corporate office of a large automotive group at the time. She was separated, but not yet divorced; and she actually has three children, including daughter Ashley (who was about 15 at the time), son Matt (about 12 then), and daughter Ginny (about 9).

In the movie: Jeffrey hacks into the store manager’s computer and changes Leigh’s work schedule.

In real life: Again, Wainscott never worked at Toys R Us. However, it’s true that Manchester was able to get into the store’s scheduling system and made changes based on who he might want working (or not working) at particular times — and perhaps just to generally create chaos.

In the movie: While spying on a conversation between Leigh and Toys R Us manager Mitch (played by Peter Dinklage), Jeffrey learns of a toy drive happening at Wainscott’s church — Crossroads, located “just across the interstate.” He starts attending the church after dropping by with a garbage bag full of stolen toys.

In real life: Somewhat true, somewhat false. In mid-fall of 2004, Manchester did in fact wander over to Crossroads Church — about 300 yards from the Toys R Us, over on Monroe Road — but mainly because he was bored and lonely after more than four months of little to no human contact. He didn’t meet Wainscott until after he started attending services. Oh, and he did bring an impressive amount of (stolen) toys to support a church toy drive, but not till closer to Christmastime.

In the movie: Jeffrey introduces himself to Leigh as John Zorn, a “just officially divorced” dad of “two little monster boys and ... a little girl that is my best pal.” He says he works for the government, but “can’t really talk about it. It’s classified.”

In real life: Mostly true. The only exception? Leigh Moore told us recently that Manchester never mentioned having kids or being married while they were dating.

In the movie: “John” and Leigh attend a singles brunch at Red Lobster, after which she asks him out.

In real life: All true, except the event was actually at TGI Friday’s.

In the movie: Leigh tells “John” her ex’s name was Jeffrey, making for a strange coincidence.

In real life: True!

In the movie: His excessively sugary diet causes Jeffrey to have to visit a nearby dentist to have 14 cavities filled.

In real life: True. We don’t know exactly how many cavities he had, but he did indeed get some filled at a dentist’s office.

In the movie: Speaking of candy, there’s a scene on Halloween when “John” and Leigh’s younger daughter Dee are shown trick-or-treating together, with him dressed as a pink bunny.

In real life: False. Manchester hadn’t even met Wainscott by Halloween of 2004. He did steal a pink bunny costume from a staff area of Toys R Us (it was used around Easter), but he wore it — for kicks — to a Christmas party hosted by a member of Crossroads Church in December.

In the movie: After a simmering rift between Leigh and her teenage daughter leads to an argument over Lindsay’s refusal to learn how to drive her mom’s stick shift, “John” announces they need a “beater” — i.e. a used automatic-transmission car that will make it easier for her to get her license. “John,” Leigh and the two girls pick out a green Chrysler Concorde sedan at a local dealership and take it for a memorably zany test drive. He winds up buying it, with a roll of cash.

In real life: Kinda, sorta true. Ish. Wainscott grew to thinking he really needed a car, so they went to a local dealership and he stunned her by plunking down $5,000 cash for a green 1999 Chrysler Concorde. None of her children went with them. The test drive was uneventful.

In the movie: Jeffrey is seen making three visits to a pawn shop. Twice, he goes when it’s open, to sell video games he stole from the toy store (at one point it’s mentioned that he stole $10,000 worth of games in total). Closer to the end, he breaks in at night and steals a pistol from a glass case along with a “POLICE” vest on a clothing rack.

In real life: Almost entirely true. Manchester did steal a significant amount of video games from the store, and pawned them. Former Charlotte police sergeant Katherine Scheimreif told us he also stole two pistols from a pawn shop farther down Independence.

In the movie: On Christmas Eve, Jeffrey robs the Toys R Us he’s been living in as it gets ready to open for the day. In the process, he knocks out and bloodies an armed security guard by striking him with his rifle.

In real life: Fairly accurate. In the course of a day-after-Christmas robbery, Manchester — wearing a vest that had “POLICE” on it — got the jump on an off-duty Mecklenburg County sheriff’s deputy who’d been hired to protect the store that morning. He took her service pistol, pointed it at her, and ordered her to the floor. He did not physically harm her, but Scheimreif told us the woman was new to her job and decided to leave the profession after being victimized.

In the movie: Jeffrey gets the big score he came for, but is thrown off his game when Leigh appears unexpectedly at the entrance. Rattled, he runs with the stolen cash to the rear of the store and flees via the emergency exit.

In real life: Fairly inaccurate. Manchester’s robbery went awry when two employees escaped while he was pulling money from the safe. He did run to the back of the store, but his plan had been to trigger the emergency-exit alarm — to make everyone think he’d left the building — and then slip through the passageway to reach his Circuit City hideout. Unfortunately for him, he forgot to trigger that alarm. Responding officers found the passageway, then found the hideout. He wasn’t in it, but they found a fingerprint that matched the escaped convict Jeffrey Manchester. Leigh didn’t find out about any of this until a week and a half later (more on that in a moment).

In the movie: Jeffrey tries to cover his tracks by burning down the dentist’s office where he had his cavities filled.

In real life: True.

In the movie: It’s implied that Leigh went to the police and then agreed to use herself as bait. As Jeffrey is on his way to the airport, to catch a flight that will take him to a country with no extradition, she calls and asks if he’s coming to Christmas dinner. He turns around and heads back to her apartment, where police are waiting to arrest him.

In real life: Mostly false, but with grains of truth. Charlotte police were showing Manchester’s photo to residents and businesses all around the Toys R Us, and finally got a hit at Crossroads Church, where members recognized him as John Zorn. They said he’d been dating Wainscott, and on Jan. 6 — her 40th birthday — police made a surprise visit to her workplace to tell her that her boyfriend was on “America’s Most Wanted.” The couple already had plans for dinner, and although Manchester knew police were onto him, Wainscott successfully got him to stick to the plan by acting calm and cool on a phone call confirming their date. He was arrested without incident outside of her apartment when he arrived to pick her up. He apparently did have plans to leave the country after taking her to dinner.

In the movie: Jeffrey is sentenced to “384 more months,” which is 32 years. “That means by the time I get out of here,” he says in voiceover, “I’ll be an old man.”

In real life: Basically false. Manchester is in Central Prison in Raleigh serving out the rest of his original 35-year sentence (for his Gaston County crimes). He did get more than 25 years for the Toys R Us crimes and the arson conviction, but the Mecklenburg judge who sentenced him in that case ordered that time be served concurrently — so he’s still expected to be released in 2036. By then, he’ll be 65 years old.

In the movie: A fellow convict asks Jeffrey if he ever got to see Leigh again. Then the film cuts to a scene in which Leigh visits Jeffrey in prison shortly after he’s recaptured. She tells him, tearfully, “I was really angry at you. I was most angry at how you hurt the girls. But that’s not the way I think about it now. I think about it as an adventure. I had a lot of fun. I’m thankful.”

In real-life: True-ish. Wainscott did make one visit to the prison afterward. She said it was just “for closure.” She then went almost two decades without talking to him, and has been happily remarried since 2016. But she reconnected with Manchester after the movie went into production — both were involved as consultants. In an interview with The Charlotte Observer last month, she said, “Yes, he broke the law. Yeah, he was a criminal. But he’s a good person.”

©2025 The Charlotte Observer. Visit charlotteobserver.com. Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.