Current News

/

ArcaMax

FDNY brothers who led rescue at Brooklyn building collapse used their father's playbook

Leonard Greene, New York Daily News on

Published in News & Features

Facing the horrific devastation before them after a three-story Brooklyn building crumbled apart and slid into a construction site next door, FDNY Chief of Rescue Operations Joseph Downey and his brother, Deputy Chief Charles Downey, knew exactly how to tackle the situation, thanks to their father, FDNY legend Ray Downey, who wrote the book on building-collapse response strategy.

“I definitely felt my father was there with us,” Chief Charles Downey, the incident commander at the Flatbush building collapse on Nov. 11, said.

Chief Ray Downey, 63, died on 9/11. As they dug through the debris at the Brooklyn collapse, his son’s mind often wandered to their time at Ground Zero as they desperately searched for their father’s remains.

“It was eerily a smaller version of those eight months we spent down at the World Trade Center,” Chief Charles Downey said.

Eight months is how long it took Charles Downey, his brother Joseph and a team of firefighters to find their father’s remains after the North Tower collapsed following the terrorist attack 25 years ago in Lower Manhattan.

Chief Raymond Downey was one of the FDNY’s most decorated firefighters and a bona fide department icon. The nickname said it all. They called him “God and Master of Disaster.”

He was a panel member of a presidential committee on terrorism, a founding member of the FEMA Urban Search & Rescue Team network and the chief in charge of the FDNY’S Special Operations Command.

Then, like now, the Downey’s used their father’s playbook to clear the rubble and pull people out alive.

With them at the Brooklyn site on Flatbush Ave. was third-generation Probationary Firefighter Joseph Downey, who was part of the bucket brigade removing debris from the pile.

By Chief Joseph Downey’s estimate, there were 300 tons of debris that hundreds of firefighters in round-the-clock shifts removed by hand over the course of 14 hours at the corner of Flatbush and Bedford Aves.

In the end, all the building’s residents and construction workers from an excavation site next door were accounted for thanks to a five-point plan put in place by the legendary fire chief whose sons carry on his legacy.

“This was a once-in-a-career collapse,” said Chief Joseph Downey Sr., 64. “To remove people alive that were still buried was mostly unheard of. Obviously, (the collapse) could have been prevented. We don’t control that.”

What they do control is sticking to the plan:

Step 1: Reconnaissance and assessment. Rescue teams have to know what they’re getting into before they start pulling from the pile.

Step 2: Rescuing victims on the surface level.

Step 3: Searching in and shoring up voids and open spaces where survivors might be.

 

Step 4: Selective debris removal.

Step 5: Reassessment and making sure that everyone is safe.

“A big part of searching that void is making sure while you’re in there and shoring it up,” Joseph Downey Sr. said. “Every time you move something, there could be a secondary movement of another area. We wanted to make sure we didn’t disturb the pile underneath.”

Among those under that pile, tucked away in one of the voids, was a pregnant woman, Fatoumata Bah. Days later, her husband, Mamadou Mouctar Balde, said his wife and unborn child were doing well, although two of his cousins, Mamadou Bhoye Barry, 23, and Mamadou Bhoye N’Diaye, 31, died in the collapse.

The cousins were among eight people killed, including two children, and 17 injured when a three-story building collapsed into an adjacent construction site.

Dramatic video from an MTA bus passing the site at 1321 Flatbush Ave. shows the exact moment the building fell apart, giving investigators more insight into what triggered the collapse.

Lawsuits have already been launched against several companies with ties to the building and construction site, alleging negligence and inadequate safety protections.

The funerals have also begun. During a service in Sunset Park, Brooklyn, for construction worker Edgar Santiago Sapón Gutiérrez, who was killed in the collapse, his grief-stricken widow fainted by her husband’s coffin and had to be rushed outside as mourners fanned her and brought her water.

Earlier this week, the city’s Department of Buildings announced it would tear down 1323 Flatbush Ave., the building next to the one that collapsed, whose side exterior wall had been ripped off, exposing the apartments inside.

“Given the dangerous condition of the building and the imperative to make sure no one else gets hurt, ordering for the controlled, safe demolition of the building is the only available option,” Building Department commissioner Ahmed Tigani said.

For the Downeys, safety is the family business.

“We’ve been on a lot of stuff together,” Chuck Downey said, recalling a Bedford-Stuyvesant fire he fought side by side with his father and brother.

And having a third generation in the mix only adds to the legacy.

“It was nice on a personal note to see my son there,” Joseph Sr. said. “It was a proud moment to work with Chuck and my son.”

_____


©2026 New York Daily News. Visit nydailynews.com. Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.

 

Comments

blog comments powered by Disqus