Muslims question political future after Florida labels biggest nonprofit 'terrorist'
Published in News & Features
The barrage of hostility Muslims have faced from Florida’s elected officials in recent years has many in the community worried about their political future in a red state that bucked the national trend of electing more Muslims into power.
Perhaps the most prominent example happened last week, when the state successfully tied the largest Muslim civil rights organization in the state of Florida to domestic terrorism, effectively shutting down the nonprofit.
Last week, the Council on American-Islamic Relations (CAIR) and its Florida chapter, CAIR-Florida, were forced to shut down all operations in the state after a federal court denied a request from CAIR to not be labeled a “domestic terrorist organization” under a new state law. The move, many advocates say, is the latest example of Florida elected officials targeting Muslim groups in an effort to strip away any mounting political power or influence.
“What Florida is doing is unprecedented. There’s no other law like this in the country,” said Hina Shamsi, the director of the ACLU National Security Project, one of the groups representing the Muslim groups in a federal lawsuit challenging the state’s “terrorist” designation.
“All of this …. is part of a campaign to relentlessly target CAIR, the largest Muslim organization in the country.”
CAIR, a nonprofit that was established over 25 years ago in Florida with chapters in 19 other states across the country — none of which have been designated a terrorist organization by the federal government — holds that it has never engaged in terrorist activity.
The move to designate CAIR as a terrorist group has garnered support from some right-wing groups and the state’s own attorney general, who called the court’s decision a “great win,” for Florida.
Meanwhile, Muslim groups and lawyers who spoke with the Miami Herald said the situation has caused a lot of “pain” in the Muslim community in Florida.
“They’ve said CAIR is no longer allowed to have a voice. The Muslims are not allowed to have a civil rights organization,” said Miami attorney and civil rights advocate Jalal Shehadeh.
Shehadeh said the governor’s history in going after Muslim groups has undoubtedly had a negative impact on the Muslim community as a whole in Florida. But what’s more concerning this time, he said, is the way the state successfully imposed a legal punishment on the group without having to prove its case in court.
“The negative reputation is seriously problematic. But what should be much more troublesome to people is that they were shut down,” Shehadeh said.
CAIR’s work in Florida ranged from pro bono legal services for residents facing government or workplace religious discrimination and those navigating the immigration system. The group also tracks anti-Muslim sentiment and hate crimes.
Normally, the federal government has authority by the Secretary of State to designate Foreign Terrorist Organizations (FTOs). Florida’s new law, which was passed earlier this year at DeSantis’ request, establishes a state-level process for designating certain groups as a domestic terrorist organization or a foreign terrorist organization. CAIR was among the first to be given the designation, along with more than 90 groups, including the Muslim Brotherhood and the anti-fascism movement known as antifa.
CAIR has argued that it is being targeted not only for its ties to the Islamic faith, but because of the group’s history of clashing with the governor on issues related to Israel. In a lawsuit filed last year, CAIR argued that its advocacy for Palestinian human rights — including its role in defending “pro-Palestinian speech” on college campuses — and criticism of Israel’s government stand in direct opposition to the viewpoints of the governor, who has been a staunch supporter of the Israeli government and its people.
Shehadeh said he worries about how the new law may be used in the future to target other groups that have been caught in the governor’s crosshairs.
“Effectively going after a Muslim organization in this way and being able to get away with it means there are many other organizations that they’re going to go after in the near future, and those may or may not be Muslim,” he said.
Last week, all CAIR employees except for the executive director, Hiba Rahim, were laid off or resigned.
In a statement to the press, Rahim said she is “heartbroken” at the decision to shutter CAIR, but that the group has “no choice but to close our doors to protect our staff and people of all faiths who support our work.”
The terrorist designation immediately makes the organization, employees and others who associate with it vulnerable to civil and criminal penalties — punishable by up to 30 years in prison.
“Florida’s new law has profoundly disturbing parallels to authoritarian states, in which political leaders silence and punish dissent without due process,” said Rahim.
On Tuesday, CAIR-Florida filed an appeal with the 11th Circuit Court of Appeals, and asked the appellate court to direct Florida to remove the “terrorist” designation while the appeal is pending.
Patterns of Islamophobia
Lawyers and advocates who spoke with the Miami Herald say the anti-Muslim rhetoric in political spaces has become somewhat normalized in Florida, leading to disparaging political attack ads, threats from Florida’s attorney general to strip some Islamic schools receiving state-funded vouchers, and public backlash against local Islamic expansion projects.
Emgage Action, a civic organization that mobilizes Muslim-American voters and other minority groups, said that the results of the midterm election — where more than a dozen Muslim politicians won their races — proved that anti-Muslim rhetoric as a political tactic “will not work on Americans.”
“Before the 2026 midterm elections Republicans tried so hard to target Muslims for their faith as a distraction from the Iran war and tariff cost crisis,” said a spokesman for Emgage Action in a statement to the Miami Herald.
“To continue this targeting after that just means that Republicans in Florida are slower to understand compared to the rest of the country, unfortunately.”
Other local Muslim groups are hoping that the new Republican governor-elect, Byron Donalds, will be open to repairing some of the tensions between segments of the Muslim community and state leadership.
Shabbir Motorwala, a founding member of the Coalition of South Florida Muslim Organizations in Miami, made this plea recently in a Palm Beach Post Op-ed, extending what he calls “an olive branch” to Donalds to talk openly about any concerns or misconceptions he might have about Muslims.
“The trend around the country is changing. Muslims are gaining acceptance in the mainstream political circle,” Motorwala told the Miami Herald. “This is going to be something you cannot ignore, and for a governor who is aspiring to be a two-term governor … if he is not going to connect with the community, then it is going to be his loss.”
Motorwala said he believes the Muslim community has been ostracized in recent years in part because of the rhetoric from elected leaders — specifically Florida Attorney General James Uthmeier. Last year, Uthmeier warned that sending vouchers to two private Islamic schools likely violates Florida law and poses a national security threat after claiming the Tampa-area Muslim schools promoted Sharia Law, a legal system and code of conduct derived from the Quran.
Motorwala said the move was damaging and spread misinformation about, Sharia law, which he compared to Halacha, or the collective body of Jewish laws, in the Jewish community.
“Sharia law is misunderstood. Nobody is saying that we are going to implement Sharia in the general community,” Motorwala said.
Earlier this year, Uthmeier again used his platform to speak out against Islamic-related activity in the state — this time directing his ire at local officials who refused to cancel a Muslim conference in Broward. Uthmeier warned Coral Springs city officials — including the city’s Jewish mayor — against supporting a Muslim conference and said the commission is “on notice” for allowing the event to move forward. The debacle raised concerns about how a community event with no proven connections to terrorism can get canceled (as it did in 2024 after facing community pressure) at the demand of Tallahassee public officials.
But the pushback is not limited just to elected officials. At a tense public meeting in early October, hundreds of residents came out to oppose an already-approved Islamic school and daycare project to be built in the county’s Agricultural Reserve. The Sun Sentinel Editorial Board blamed hate-filled social media algorithms for the “curated rage over a three-year-old zoning decision.” Some believed the debate highlighted genuine concerns over the expansion in the Ag Reserve, while others detected clear expressions of intolerance for the Muslim community.
Motorwala is hopeful that Florida’s new leadership will push the reset button on Muslim community relations.
“The Muslim community has been marginalized since 9/11, and CAIR played a very important role to make sure that the civil rights of the American Muslims, again the word is American Muslims, are not violated,” Motorwala said.
©2026 Miami Herald. Visit at miamiherald.com. Distributed by Tribune Content Agency, LLC.









Comments